I just bought this and so far, it is fine. I am not that particular but I do want the dish soaps I use to be safe for the earth and still clean the dishes. This one seems to fit the bill.
This is a Ecover soap is pretty decent. It does a good job cleaning most dishes and it's gentle on your hands. Not to mention, it's made of a lot of natural ingredients and is biodegradable! The scent is very light, unlike a lot of conventional dish soaps. It does suds a little too much for my liking. I'd probably buy it again.
I feel this is just a plain jane dishwashing liquid. It does its job. Gets the dirt and grease out with hand scrubbing action. Smells nice.
I just came off of using a really powerful concentrated liquid. Going from that to this regular liquid is a self made let down. I used far more of this liquid than I did of the other product. Makes me feel guilty for supporting shipped water.
Not bad at all. Its just a generic liquid that has less bad chemicals in it.